When you're about to start learning to drive, it's important to take the time to consider whether it would be better to learn in a manual or in an automatic. To help you decide, here's a quick and easy overview of the advantages and disadvantages of each transmission system.

The Advantages and Disadvantages of Manual

Probably the most compelling argument in favour of learning to drive a manual is that you will subsequently be comfortable driving an automatic as well. Making the switch from automatic to manual is much harder, and you often won't have a choice in the matter. For example, hiring a car in certain countries will often mean having no choice but manual.

At the same time, manual transmission systems let you control your drive more directly, making shifts when you feel it is necessary. This becomes particularly advantageous if you're driving over slippery surfaces, and it typically means that you'll burn less fuel. Manual cars are also cheaper to buy since their gearboxes are far less complicated.

However, there's no denying that manual cars are harder to drive. Synchronising the clutch with the gears - often referred to as 'finding the biting point' – can be tricky, especially for new drivers. Many learners frequently stall, which can be slightly distressing with a queue of traffic behind you. This means you'll probably need to spend more money taking driving lessons.

The Advantages and Disadvantages of Automatic

Few people would argue against the idea that driving an automatic is much easier. With only two pedals, all you have to do is put the car in either drive or reverse, then control braking and acceleration.

Driving through busy towns and cities in a manual requires constant gear changing, and it can be slightly overwhelming having to maintain control of the vehicle while also keeping your eyes on the road. This isn't an issue when driving an automatic, so many learners prefer to learn and take their test in one simply to get on the road faster. Ongoing convenience is also a factor; if you just like to sit back and enjoy the ride, automatic is the way to go.

However, the lack of control may bother some drivers since power doesn't feel quite as direct. Additionally, the reduced efficiency of an automatic often becomes problematic, as does the fact that you won't be able to drive a manual.

Your decision ultimately depends upon your own needs. Essentially, manual vehicles come with a number of advantages, but are harder to learn in, while automatic vehicles are easier and more convenient to drive, especially in high-traffic areas, but those who learn in them won't be able to handle a manual or take advantage of its benefits.

Share